Kashmir cannot be solved bilaterally except on the basis of the status quo. Connectivities are never exclusive but the political implications are clear when China becomes lender of first resort rather than the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank put together.The Responsibility to Protect doctrine will be back on the shelf where it belongs. As for humanitarian arguments, such reasoning has been appropriated by Russia in Georgia and Ukraine.. India is one of the world’s big economies, but big-player status is difficult without being pivotal in South Asia where India’s leadership is insufficiently credible. Opponents will be regarded as enemies.
The oil monopoly of the Middle East and its political influence will diminish sharply.On the “frozen” disputes of Cyprus, Palestine, Ukraine and North Korea, little progress is possible unless Washington’s position changes on the last three. Russia and China are not the only countries to believe they have a different kind of civilisation where sovereignty trumps democracy and stability trumps human rights.The World Trade Organisation will fall into disuse, unable to engineer global agreements. Action to protect the environment against global warming, despite US opposition, has a greater chance of success.
The Belt and Road Initiative will succeed in bringing Central Asia, Eurasia and West Europe into greater economic cooperation and enabling China’s reach into Latin America and Africa.To look too far into the future is speculative: 2025 is a better horizon; President Donald Trump will have finished a possible second term; Prime Minister Narendra Modi will have finished his second term, and China’s targets set by President Xi Jinping can be assessed.The desire for freedom is universal, but freedom to shatter the economy in protests as in Hong Kong, or freedom to blaspheme as in the French Charlie Hebdo or Russian Pussy Riot cases, or freedom to bear arms as enshrined in the American Constitution, are examples that show that liberty has limitations, even if self-imposed.
The relative success of street protests in Algeria, Sudan, Iraq, France, Ecuador, Catalonia and Hong Kong are indications that this trend will continue, driven by the social media. So, whether or not Mr Trump is re-elected, the America First doctrine will endure.The West will attempt to drive a wedge between Russia and China, but the price to pay for this will be high.In many countries, populist-nationalist parties have squeezed traditional political parties; only they seem to fire up enthusiasm among voters. The ability of intelligence agencies worldwide against terrorism has enormously increased. The green movement will continue to grow, but remain on the political fringes for want of corporate financing. The Western flagship model of democracy and free market prolonged itself through widening the franchise, but voters everywhere distrust elected representatives and democracy looks headed for a long drawn out decline.
This makes US foreign policy essentially bilateral, generating less chance for the expansion of permanent membership of the UN Security Council to which India aspires. President Xi Jinping has set 10 objectives for global leadership for China by 2025; among them, Artificial Intelligence, driverless cars, robotics, and quantum engineering.The race is on for supremacy in artificial intelligence and 5G. No country will find the golden mean between free-range liberalism and statism. It will be impossible to distinguish between the role of intelligence organisations and conventional diplomacy. Interference in elections by the US, Russia, China and smaller fry will increase.
If the situation in Kashmir deteriorates, the issue may be revived in international forums, although no third party has enthusiasm for India-Pakistan disputes. Financial corporates made profits in globalisation while the working class lost jobs; in the United States, the average income of the top one per cent is 138 times higher than the bottom 50 per cent. An India-China war is also unlikely, but China will use Pakistan as a proxy to hinder India’s rise.Leaks are a feature of American politics ever since the founding fathers and will grow apace. The Zelensky telephone scandal will make every foreign leader cautious in talking to the US President. Despite the slowdown, China grows at around six per cent and will overtake America’s GDP before 2030. Impeachment will be on the agenda if Mr Trump wins a second term.In the US, Europe and everywhere, it will be harder for the minorities, refugees, economic migrants and asylum seekers.
The role of the intelligence agencies will grow with technological capability; governments will increasingly rely on them and eventually be in thrall to them. The growth of India’s economy and the democratic system remains our best insurance policy.The time has come for a new Geneva Convention to replace the existing four, a new global agreement to replace the WTO, and treaties on the use of plastics and ocean sanctuaries. Cyber attacks will proliferate.America perceives China as its greatest threat. Iran and the South China Sea are unlikely to cause accidents, but North Korea may. The International Criminal Court will remain without credibility. Iran will continue to be a stone in the throat of the West. It is arguable that China and India no longer deserve special differentiated status as developing nations.Muslim grievances, which can take extremist form, will remain as long as the Kashmir and Palestine issues remain unresolved and the Shias believe the West is hostile.
The quality of democratic debate will plummet. The public is abandoning mainstream political parties because the social contract that promised equal opportunity and rising incomes for both the elites and the masses is discredited. So too Turkey, to a lesser extent.The mainstream media will be on the defensive to show accuracy as it scrambles to compete with an ever-growing number of news sources. The same is the case with India, where the number of road deaths is 364 times higher than terrorism casualties.Eighteen years after the Twin Towers fell, 75 per cent of Americans call terrorism a national priority Poly Spandex fabric and 50 per cent prioritise security over civil liberties, but the number of fatalities directly attributed to terror is microscopic compared to the 700 killings a year by so-called law enforcement agencies. India, Turkey, Iran and many others feel they present an alternative model to Western-style liberalism. India’s efforts to normalise relations with China will flounder because of Pakistan.Mr Trump’s foreign policies are more popular than commonly perceived, with support for isolationist and protectionist policies.
In international relations, the centre ground for concepts like strategic autonomy will shrink with polarisation, and affect countries like India, which has already, with a wary eye on China and Pakistan, moved towards a more aligned position with all the liabilities that this entails. China’s rise is something that the world has to adjust to. The West will regret their refusal to grant China its rightful share of control in the multilateral financial institutions.There is unlikely to be a China-US war other than by accident.Liberalism is used in India today to attack the government and by the government against its detractors. Multilateralism is also the means to counter trends towards unilateralism, ethnocentrism, protectionism and racial intolerance.Multilateralism is the answer to managing China’s rise. China is regarded as an affront, since the presumption is that being American implies Number One status
qwer